Photo: Bokeh / Tomedia. Cityscape with Historic Domes and Trees.
If somebody offers you a large number of backlinks, I would like to know what those links are before becoming impressed by the number.
A link is a real thing on a real page. Someone put it there, with some wording around it, for some reason. Looking at that page tells you considerably more than a promise that the links are all high quality.
Where a link came from, what it says and why someone put it there matter. Combining them into a total makes the report easier to read, but hides the details you need to judge the work.
Open the page
Start with an ordinary reader’s experience. Does the page have a subject? Is the link useful within that subject? Does it help somebody find an explanation, a source, a business or a product they have a reason to visit?
A relevant link in a useful article has a reason to be there. A page containing unrelated paragraphs and oddly specific links deserves a closer look. You don’t need to know the exact workings of a search engine to ask why that page exists.
I wouldn’t judge the whole thing by a third-party authority score either. A score can help you sort a large collection of pages for investigation. It cannot replace reading the page that will link to your business.
Nor would I treat a domain ending as a guarantee. The actual page and the reason for the reference still matter. A link on a neglected corner of a respected institution’s website doesn’t automatically become a meaningful recommendation from that institution.
What are you paying for?
There are legitimate reasons to pay for advertising and sponsorship. You may want to reach the readers of a publication, support an event or explain a product to a relevant audience. Be clear about that arrangement.
Google’s link guidance recommends marking paid placements with the sponsored attribute. It also provides attributes for user-generated links and other situations. These tell search engines what kind of link it is. Keep them even if someone promises you a more valuable link without them.
Ask a supplier to explain what they will arrange and how it will appear. If the entire proposal depends on concealing payment so that an advertisement looks like an independent endorsement, I would want to know why that is the plan before agreeing to it.
Google includes buying or selling links for ranking manipulation in its link spam policies. A promise of guaranteed rankings doesn’t make that arrangement less of a gamble for the website receiving the links.
Writing somewhere else can have a sensible purpose
Guest articles can put useful information in front of a different audience. The test is whether you have something relevant to contribute to that publication and its readers.
Work out what the article gives them. A clear explanation based on work you understand is a reasonable starting point. A generic article written around the requirement to insert a particular commercial phrase is a much less convincing one.
I would apply that judgement even if search engines didn’t exist. Would you still want the article to appear there? Would you send a potential customer to it? Would you be comfortable explaining how the placement came about?
These questions make it harder to buy a package you cannot explain afterwards.
Ask for examples before a spreadsheet
When you review a proposal, ask to see the kinds of pages involved and the terms of the placement. Then decide whether the audience, subject and relationship make sense for your business. Keep those details in the reporting so the number doesn’t become the entire result.
For more on assessing links, you can buy The Big Book of SEO on Ephemera. Before paying for the next backlink package, ask the person selling it to open a few of the pages with you. You should be able to explain why you want your business on them.



